On or about 1977, John Archibald Wheeler spoke at the Hebb Theater at UBC, and I was there. The title of the talk, as I recall, was "The End of Physics?". Wheeler was one of the preeminent physicists of his day. He used to live next to Einstein and knew more about gravity than just about anyone. He literally wrote the book (Gravitation) on the subject. Richard P. Feynman was his student. Without question, if you were to name the top five theoretical physicists of the 20th century, they would be among them. A third would be Einstein. Others possible candidates include giants like GellMan, Pauli, Dyson (of Dyson Sphere fame), Heisenberg, Bohr, and recent Nobel winner Kip Thorne. While priests stare into their navels to try to find the secrets of the universe, Feynman and Wheeler, the protagonists of the book, were looking to nature to answer the big questions. Both Feynman and Wheeler were skeptics. Feynman liked the phrase "Cargo Cult Science" (read Guns, Germs and Steel by Jarod Diamond for more on Cargo Cults). The author is himself a physicist which helps a lot in the narrative. Feynman and Wheeler were quite different people. Wheeler's thoughts would often stray to the philosophical, whereas Feynman took one course in philosophy to get his Art points for his degree (something he and I have in common), and thought it all rubbish. The thoughts of both men were unconstrained by conventional thinking and often bent to the philisophical. A good example: Wheeler once suggested that all electrons are identical to each other because they are all the same electron! He also suggested that positrons (antielectrons) are electrons moving backward in time (mostly because the math worked). Now that is thinking outside the box. The universe is very strange and we literally do not have the language or experience to explain it. But to a physicist, whatever the explanations, the math must work out. Feynman invented a mathematical trick called the "sum of histories" that got rid of pesky infinities and gave real answers to quantum mechanical problems. Oddly, QED (Quantum Electrodynamics), is the most accurate theory in physics history, but Feynman was always leery of it because he did not trust the math… his own math. Wheeler gave rise to the idea of "wormholes", which has become a SciFi staple. Both physicists dismissed the idea of wormhole travel (it would require matter with antigravity, and the machinery would have the mass of a galaxy) as implausible. Wheeler in later life would turn to an information based view of physics. Another reflection of his philosophical bent. Bohr once said "Philosophy is too important to be left to philosophers." and Wheeler agreed. Both physicists struggled with the nature of time and the book gives the usual discussions of thermodynamics in that regard. The book tells the very human story of both protagonists. Feynman was a hound, but when he finally found the right woman, he stuck with her. His swan song was the Oring Challenger disaster story (there is a good movie on that subject with William Hurt). While Feynman was freespirited, Wheeler was more of a homebody/family man. Wheeler died in 2008; Feynman died of cancer in 1988. As mentioned, Wheeler liked the idea of information as the basis for physics. He was inspired by rapid advances in information theory and in computing in general. Sadly, Feynman tied too soon to really see what modern computing can really do. He would have loved it. Future physicists will be able to manipulate formulae as they always have, but now with the aid of computers to make sure they got it right. And more importantly they will be able to see the results in real time in graphical form. Kepler spent years grinding numbers to validate his three laws. With a modern computer, he would have been able to see the theory and the observations line up before him. What the next Feynman will be able to do with such tools is what keeps the game interesting. In one amusing anecdote, Feynman (I think) forgot the location of a large physics conference. He had an idea, and asked the driver if any of his fares had used words like covariant and "geuvee" (he might have said "geemoonoo" using Greek letters). He had, and Feynman said, "Take me to where you took them." This was an unexplained inside joke. "Geeuve" is actually Guv (where u and v are subscripts). Guv appears in Einstein's field equations all over the place. It is known as the "metric tensor". The "metric" is essentially a description of the shape of a mathematical space, and it is a corner stone of general relativity. I really liked this book. No math. Lots of mindbending ideas. And real lives.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. 
AuthorLee Moller is a lifelong skeptic and atheist and the author of The God Con. Archives
January 2024
Categories
All
